Criminal Law and Philosophy
Publisher: Springer Nature · ISSN 1871-9791,1871-9805 · 25 articles
-
Who Should Enforce Morality?
This essay evaluates Steven Wall's ethical environmentalist defense of legal moralism and legal paternalism. Section II summarizes Wall's account of the permissible use of state power to enforce broad morality and raises epistemic...
-
Consequentialism, Threshold Retributivism, and Moral Intuitions
The purpose of Adam Kolber’s magnificent book is to show that a consequentialist theory of punishment is superior to standard retributivism. In this comment I argue that Kolber is right when he rejects the claim that the traditional...
-
Consequentialism About Incarceration: Comments on Kolber
Kolber’s magnificent book argues that “pure consequentialism is superior to standard retributivism when applied to incarceration in the here and now.” I admire his focus on actual contexts and particular cases of incarceration, and I...
-
Retributivism and Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt: A Response to Adam Kolber on the Riskiness of Retributivism
Adam Kolber argues that retributivists should insist not just that factual guilt is established beyond a reasonable doubt before they endorse punishment, they should condition punishment on proving that the defendant deserves to be...
-
Kolber on the Justificatory Standard of Proof
Adam Kolber’s book, Punishment for the Greater Good, offers a powerful argument for the claim that retributivism is false. This paper reconstructs the argument and offers an objection. The objection involves rejecting a particular view...
-
‘Privacy at the Limits of Control’
A great deal of common law jurisprudence—especially within criminal and constitutional law—treats an agent’s control as a primary (though not the sole) factor in determining the scope of the agent’s reasonable expectation of privacy. We...
-
Mutually Unjust Wars
According to contemporary just war theory waging a just war requires that a belligerent fulfill a number of stringent conditions such as just cause, proportionality, and necessity. Failing to fulfill any of them would render a war un...
-
The Perils of Punishment Definition Agnosticism
Kolber’s Punishment for the Greater Good solidifies his reputation as the most astute living critic of retributive theories of punishment. But his book does not even attempt to defend a consequentialist alternative. Instead, he hopes to...
-
Defining the Wrongness Constraint
The idea that the wrongfulness of conduct is necessary for its criminalization to be permissible (or justified or legitimate), is widely endorsed, and even more widely discussed, in criminal law theory. However, there are significant...
-
Punishment and Regret
This essay is a contribution to a symposium on Adam Kolber’s Punishment for the Greater Good. As the title suggests, the essay focuses on the issues of punishment and regret. Its main thrust is a critique of Kolber’s failure to...
-
Punishment for the Greater Good: Replies to Critics
In my book, Punishment for the Greater Good , I raised a question punishment theorists rarely address: if we seek a moral theory that speaks to real-world punishment today, which theory should we use? My thesis is that, in the here and...
- The Deontological Ethics of Punishment
- Wall Jesse, Sex and Self-Ownership (Oxford: Oxford University Press), p. 218.£ 100
- PhD Dissertation: The Liberal Tension of the Adversarial Criminal Trial: A Liberal Institution in the Administration of Criminal Justice
-
Theorising the Criminal Law’s Person: Perspectives on the Human Individual, Problems of Assumed Properties, and Normative Solutions
This is the abstract of my dissertation, Theorising the Criminal Law’s Person: Perspectives on the Human Individual , Problems of Assumed Properties , and Normative Solutions , which was accepted by the Faculty of Law at the University...
- Overinclusive Offences and Conflicting Duties in Criminal Law
-
Moral Theory and the Justification of Punishment: Comments on Adam Kolber’s Punishment for the Greater Good
This comment on Adam Kolber’s Punishment for the Greater Good (Oxford 2024) gives an interpretation of Kolber’s project according to which the aim is to provide a public standard for assessing the discretionary decisions of legal actors...
-
Abolition Feminism and the Practice of Policing
In November of 2021, more than a year after the public execution of George Floyd by local police officers, Minneapolis voters rejected an amendment to its city charter (‘Question 2’) to abolish its police department. One of the most...
-
The Pro-Tanto Wrongfulness of Sexual Exploitation: A Context-Sensitive Approach from India
What makes sexual exploitation pro-tanto wrongful, even when it is mutually beneficial and non-coercive? This paper argues that the exploiter wrongs the exploitee by breaching two duties: not to take advantage of a person in a situation...
-
From Imperium to Ius Puniendi: On the Distinction Between Punishment and Enforcement
In ancient Rome all magistrates or public authorities had potestas, i.e., powers to carry out their duties or civil responsibilities which was derived from a general and sometimes absolute power to rule called imperium. In most cases,...
-
Pain Matters? The New Life of Poena Naturalis
What purpose does legal punishment serve when the offender is already enduring profound suffering as a consequence of the offence itself? This paper addresses that question through the concept of poena naturalis: the severe suffering...
-
Corporate Crime and Conceptions of a Corporate Person
I argue that our understanding of the basis for corporate criminal liability and punishment would be enhanced by bringing out the different conceptions of the company that the law commonly employs, in shaping liability and justifying...
-
Culpability: its Nature and Role in Punishable Blameworthiness
The article explores culpability as the moral property that along with wrongdoing determines an actor’s responsibility for some bad state of affairs. Two main theories of culpability are distinguished, the voluntarist and the quality of...
-
Tough on Criminalizing Begging and Sleeping Rough
Many state and local governments have passed laws that criminalize sleeping rough and passive begging. However, little attention has been directed toward the basic moral question of whether sleeping rough and begging are types of...
-
Against the View of the Criminal Trial as “Calling Defendants to Account”
The conventional view is that the purpose of a criminal trial is to determine whether the defendant committed a crime and, if so, what the appropriate legal response should be. This view has been criticized for failing to justify...