Criminal Law and Philosophy Law

Kolber on the Justificatory Standard of Proof

Yaffe, Gideon
Springer Nature · 2026-10-01 · DOI 10.1007/s11572-025-09764-9

Abstract

Adam Kolber’s book, Punishment for the Greater Good, offers a powerful argument for the claim that retributivism is false. This paper reconstructs the argument and offers an objection. The objection involves rejecting a particular view that Kolber offers about the rationality of an intention to punish, a view according to which one cannot rationally intend to punish without a high degree of credence that punishing is justified. It is argued that this is too high a standard for the rationality of intention.

Read at publisher →