Criminal Law and Philosophy Право

The Pro-Tanto Wrongfulness of Sexual Exploitation: A Context-Sensitive Approach from India

Chaudhary, Shraddha
Springer Nature · 2026-09-06 · DOI 10.1007/s11572-026-09814-w

Аннотация

What makes sexual exploitation pro-tanto wrongful, even when it is mutually beneficial and non-coercive? This paper argues that the exploiter wrongs the exploitee by breaching two duties: not to take advantage of a person in a situation where he should not, and to treat her with the respect she deserves as a human being. Three conditions together explain when and why these duties are breached: vulnerability, unwantedness and degradation. Each is a necessary condition, but all three conditions together constitute the wrong of sexual exploitation. The exploiter takes advantage of the exploitee’s morally relevant vulnerability to obtain her consent to sexual acts that are unwanted as sexual acts. Those unwanted acts, chosen under conditions of vulnerability, degrade her. Degradation, on this account, is structural and contextual. The historical and continued use of sexual acts as instruments of domination and subordination in patriarchy imbues all sexual acts with the possibility of degradation. However, it is when unwanted sexual acts are chosen under conditions of morally relevant vulnerability that this possibility is actualised, and the wrong of sexual exploitation occurs. While sexual acts carry this possibility across patriarchal contexts, India’s caste-based patriarchy adds an additional dimension to the degradation of Indian women, due to their instrumentalisation and objectification for the maintenance of caste purity and honour.

Читать у издателя →