Kolber’s magnificent book argues that “pure consequentialism is superior to standard retributivism when applied to incarceration in the here and now.” I admire his focus on actual contexts and particular cases of incarceration, and I accept his main criticisms of standard retributivism. However, I reply that pure consequentialism faces several profound problems similar to those he presses against standard retributivism. In particular, I argue that pure consequentialism is not as simple, practical, or fruitful as Kolber claims, and that it has trouble dealing with uncertainty and aligning with intuition and conventional morality. In the end, Kolber fails to show that pure consequentialism is any good in the here and now or superior to standard retributivism in any important sense.
Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter. Consequentialism About Incarceration: Comments on Kolber. // Criminal Law and Philosophy. – 2026. – DOI: 10.1007/s11572-025-09754-x. – URL: http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11572-025-09754-x
Sinnott-Armstrong & Walter (2026). Consequentialism About Incarceration: Comments on Kolber. Criminal Law and Philosophy. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11572-025-09754-x
Sinnott-Armstrong and Walter. “Consequentialism About Incarceration: Comments on Kolber.” Criminal Law and Philosophy, 2026. doi:10.1007/s11572-025-09754-x.
@article{SinnottArmstrong2026,
title = {Consequentialism About Incarceration: Comments on Kolber},
author = {Sinnott-Armstrong and Walter},
journal = {Criminal Law and Philosophy},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1007/s11572-025-09754-x},
url = {http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11572-025-09754-x}
}
Homicide statistics per police district in the city of Chicago from the years 1964–2018 are demonstrated to fit a logarithmic distribution, which may have consequences regarding how police departments should allocate resources. In...
Most criminal justice administrative databases lack an identifier for veteran status. As a result, analyses of military veterans’ offending often use prison-based samples or rely upon self-identification, which can omit critical...
Abundant prior research has shown that patterns of criminal sentencing often vary according to the characteristics of defendants and court communities, even under presumptive guidelines systems that are intended to reduce these...
Research continuously shows that crime concentrates in micro-geographic places, leading Weisburd (2015) to propose a law of crime concentration. Scholars testing the law find remarkable consistency across place and time. However, the...
A body of research has examined the consequences associated with being processed through the criminal justice system. The current study built upon this literature by examining whether probation and incarceration were differentially...