Who Should Enforce Morality?

Radzik, Linda
Criminal Law and Philosophy · Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI: 10.1007/s11572-026-09816-8

Аннотация

This essay evaluates Steven Wall's ethical environmentalist defense of legal moralism and legal paternalism. Section II summarizes Wall's account of the permissible use of state power to enforce broad morality and raises epistemic objections. Section III provides an argument for preferring alternative, social methods for enforcing ethics. Section IV presents some examples of duties of broad morality that are (with rare exceptions) left solely to social enforcement in the United States but that are backed by legal sanctions in many other countries–filial responsibility laws and bad Samaritan laws. These examples of legal moralism are built upon ethical judgments in which we have a lot of confidence, and so they lend support to Wall's position. However, in the end, I believe they reveal additional reasons for preferring social (rather than legal) methods for enforcing morality.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи