Acta Analytica
Издатель: Springer Nature · ISSN 0353-5150,1874-6349 · 25 статей
-
What Do We Owe Experts? Epistemic Authority and Social Responsibility
This paper develops a normative account of our epistemic duties towards experts and expertise, advancing two complementary models of such duties. In an optimisation model, disregarding expertise constitutes a violation of the general...
-
Personal and Subpersonal Explanations in Forensic Psychiatry: A Co-evolutionary Perspective
Doubts about an offender’s criminal competence typically lead courts to mandate a psychiatric evaluation to determine whether a mental disorder impaired the defendant’s capacity to understand their actions or to control their will....
-
The Non-Reductionist View of the Self in Tension with the Block Universe
This paper advances the thesis that there is a substantive tension between the Non- Reductionist View of the Self , according to which the self is fundamental (irreducible to physical or psychological states or processes) and...
-
Platonism in Better Shape
Platonism about properties holds that there are uninstantiated properties. For properties do not depend on their instances, whereas their instances depend on them. In this paper, I shall discuss two ‘heterodox’ versions of Platonism...
-
The Prudential 'Now What?' Problem
The ‘Now What?’ problem for moral error theorists concerns whether (and how) error theorists should maintain or abolish moral discourse. If moral discourse is systematically error-ridden, one must decide whether to abandon it, as we...
-
The Logic of Proper Accidents
This paper offers a formal and exegetical analysis of the notion of proprium (proper accident), a concept rooted in Aristotelian logic and further developed by Thomas Aquinas and other medievals. While commonly defined as a property...
-
Intuition is Evidence
Intuition is a psychological state that often accompanies some propositions, particularly when engaging in thought experiments. I argue that these intuitive states can sometimes serve as evidence for the propositions they accompany. To...
-
Social Progress: When and How? Two Conservative Responses and Their Limits
In this paper I examine two common conservative responses to two questions about social progress: How should social progress be pursued? And when does social change constitute social progress? These two responses can be summarised as...
-
Modelling Collective Epistemic Trust
This project explores the intersection of two lively debates in epistemology that have not yet engaged with each other: accounts of group belief in collective epistemology and work the nature of epistemic trust. As social epistemology...
-
Armchair Epistemology: Knowledge, Necessity, and Epistemic Luck
In “Armchair Luck” (2007a), Nenad Miščević argues that Duncan Pritchard’s safe-true-belief anti-luck epistemology cannot rule out a priori veritic luck. Since a priori necessary truths are true in all possible worlds, Pritchard’s safety...
-
Disentangling GPS from Nudging: Why the Distinction Matters for the Ethics of Nudging
Nudge theory proposes to deliberately alter people’s behaviour or choices for their welfare. Based on insights from behavioural economics, choice architects intentionally design nudges to influence agents’ behaviour or choices towards...
-
Terminal Boredom, Longevity, and Narrative
I argue for a longevity interpretation of Bernard Williams’s argument against the desirability of immortality and employ it to analyze and critique John Martin Fischer’s narrative model of immortality. According to the interpretation I...
-
Physicalism, Continuity, and the Changing Face of Physics
The via negativa conception of physicalism defines the thesis in terms of the exclusion of fundamental mentality: no property is both fundamental and mental. I argue that its appeal is best understood as resting on a deeper metaphysical...
-
In Defense of Epistemic Perceptualism
Epistemic perceptualism is the view that emotions provide immediate prima facie justification for evaluative beliefs. I defend this view against recent criticism by Michael Brady. I address two of his arguments in particular: what I...
-
Memory Scepticism and Particularism
Memory sceptics typically argue that we don’t possess memory knowledge because our memory beliefs are underdetermined by memorial evidence. In response, the particularist anti-sceptical proposal argues that our anti-sceptical beliefs...
-
Reconfiguring Epistemic Reparations Through a Decolonial Lens
This paper reconfigures epistemic reparations through a decolonial lens. Shifting away from reparations as restoring the victim’s epistemic standing to contribute to a “common pool of knowledge,” we focus on epistemic sovereignty. In so...
-
Epistemologizing Technology: On the Technological Scaffolding of Epistemic Exchanges and Violence
Bringing together Philosophy of Technology and Social Epistemology, this paper investigates how technology can engender worlds and affective atmospheres that structure epistemic exchanges. In addition to mediating the perception and...
-
Conspiracy Theorists and Appreciating Evidence
Debates on the rationality of endorsing conspiracy theories often focus on the primary evidence conspiracy theorists have: errant data, eyewitnesses, revealed documentation, and the kind of facts typical investigators would use. Once we...
-
Judgment, Reality, and Temporality: Gareth Evans Reconsidered
Gareth Evans infers the absoluteness of truth and reality from the absoluteness of the correctness of assertion: since the correctness of assertion does not vary with time, he concludes that truth and reality cannot vary with time...
-
On Wholehearted Decisions
To complete his theory of free will, Harry Frankfurt introduces the condition of wholeheartedness. Specifically, he asserts that one’s will is free if and only if their second-order volition endorses their first-order desire to pursue...
-
Common Knowledge Attainability: A Response to Lederman’s Sailboat Argument
Common knowledge requires that everyone knows a proposition, knows that everyone knows it, and so on. Lederman’s Sailboat Argument claims that ideal agents may fail to attain common knowledge. The argument appeals to small differences...
-
Unjustified Defeaters and the Role of Incoherence in Epistemic Defeat
This paper examines the possibility of unjustified defeaters and the explanatory role of incoherence in epistemic defeat. I reconstruct Peter Graham and Jack Lyons’s objections to Jennifer Lackey’s psychological defeaters, paying...
-
Can Normativity Be Fictional?
The article examines whether normativity itself, rather than merely normative statements or facts represented within fiction, can be fictional. The question is distinguished from the problem of imaginative resistance introduced by K....
- Introduction to the Collection
-
The Battlefield of Indeterminate Causation and its Additivity
A number of philosophers have argued that causation can be indeterminate, particularly in cases of causation by omission such as Sartorio’s Battlefield . In Battlefield , an inaction is followed by the deaths of three soldiers, though...