Correspondence: fundamental theoretical and mathematical flaws in “Enhancing phase noise performance in cross-coupled LC oscillators through switch transistor current shaping”

Engineering in Extreme Environments · Springer Nature · 2026-11-07 · DOI: 10.1007/s10470-026-02681-4

Аннотация

This correspondence provides a mathematically grounded critique of the paper by Yazdani, Jalali, and Hashemipour [1]. Three categories of severe errors are identified and analysed. First, the reported work fundamentally misinterprets the Hajimiri–Lee linear time-variant (LTV) phase-noise model and the impulse sensitivity function (ISF), treating the latter as a design parameter that can be arbitrarily modified by passive component insertion. Second, the derivation from the Adler injection-locking equation contains multiple independent mathematical fallacies: a spurious factor of $$\pi$$ that underestimates the locking range by a factor of $$\pi$$, dimensional inconsistency, and a physically forbidden dependence on an arbitrary initial phase that produces an unphysical peak-to-peak oscillation of approximately 4.77 dB. Third, the reported figure of merit of 198.10 dBc/Hz and the implied noise factor $$F\approx 1.08$$ lie outside the analytical bounds for MOSFET-based LC oscillators, and the reported $$+8$$ dB phase-noise improvement exceeds the analytically proven Mazzanti–Andreani Class-C ceiling of 3.9 dB by more than a factor of two. Four closed-form, reproducible results are presented; each uses only the paper’s own reported parameters, so the reader can verify every claim without proprietary tools. We conclude that the errors are irreparable and that the paper’s central claims are not supported.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи