Network-based clustering of cognitive profiles: a comparative two-phase approach mitigating double-dipping estimation

Current Robotics Reports · Springer Nature · 2026-10-28 · DOI: 10.1007/s10260-026-00890-9

Аннотация

Network psychometrics has emerged as a powerful framework for understanding cognitive functioning, yet clustering individuals based on network dissimilarity poses methodological challenges. Traditional approaches that apply statistical thresholding during cluster optimization risk circular analysis and overfitting. We propose a two-phase network-based clustering method that separates exploratory cluster identification from confirmatory inference. Phase 1 optimizes cluster assignments using weighted, unthresholded correlation networks and comparing results across three dissimilarity metrics (Frobenius distance, DeltaCon, and spectral distance). Phase 2 characterizes identified clusters using permutation-based network estimation with statistical thresholding. The proposed approach was validated on simulated data and applied to a motivating empirical cognitive dataset, where it was compared with traditional single-phase methods and evaluated in terms of stability across dissimilarity metrics. In simulations with known ground truth, Frobenius distance provided the best partition recovery across all scenarios, outperforming DeltaCon and spectral distance. Although individual-level recovery was moderate, the Frobenius-based algorithm successfully reproduced the main population-level network contrasts, particularly in signed and sparse-versus-dense structures. Applied to cognitive data from N=4471 participants across 7 cognitive domains, the two-phase approach avoided inflated dissimilarity estimates while maintaining computational efficiency. The final Frobenius-based empirical solution identified two qualitatively distinct cognitive network profiles: a sparser, more modular profile characterized by domain-specific associations, and a dense, globally integrated profile with stronger connectivity across cognitive domains. The two-phase framework provides methodologically rigorous network-based clustering that avoids circular analysis. This approach is applicable to psychological, neuroscience, and clinical research where network structure differs across subgroups.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи