Journal of Academic Ethics Философия

Accountable Interdependence in Publications from Shared Data

Le, Thanh Thao, Pham, Trut Thuy
Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI 10.1007/s10805-026-09779-4

Аннотация

Several worthwhile papers can arise from the same dataset, yet unnecessary fragmentation can obscure findings and misrepresent the amount of independent evidence. This conceptual article develops Writing-With as an approach to evaluating relationships among such publications. Accountable interdependence describes the responsible management of shared evidence when each paper has a defensible contribution and the relevant connections are disclosed. It accommodates papers that answer separate questions as well as papers that extend the interpretation of earlier findings. Four dimensions organise this assessment: relational responsibility, reflexive justification, recursive reconsideration, and re-forming contribution. Published examples from a blood-pressure trial and an educational experiment show why shared provenance, overlapping observations, and interpretive connections require different judgements. A hypothetical borderline case examines when an additional subgroup paper warrants separate publication. A worked publication genealogy records material overlap and explains the contribution of each output. The approach supports proportionate assessment of related papers while recognising that neither disclosure nor conceptual connectedness establishes publication legitimacy on its own. Future research should examine whether the genealogy improves editorial decisions and how its usefulness varies across disciplines.

Читать у издателя →