Review of Philosophy and Psychology Philosophy
Intrusive Memories
Abstract
Intrusive memories are characteristic of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and occur in other mental-health disorders. Their features suggest a potentially important, under-explored, class of memories. I consider a classification puzzle arising from analyses of intrusive memories, which is generated by tensions between features of “standard” forms of remembering and features of intrusive memories. I argue that widely accepted features of episodic memory—an initially plausible form of memory on which to focus when classifying intrusive memories—cannot easily figure in a satisfactory explanation of these phenomena. This raises the possibility either that there are deviant or mutated forms of episodic memory, or that standard taxonomies of memory require substantive revision. I develop an alternative solution to the classification puzzle: an explanation of intrusive memories in terms of recognition memory, which avoids the explanatory deficits of focusing on remembering episodically and affords additional explanatory benefits.