Ethical Theory and Moral Practice Философия

Merit, Demeaning Actions, and Reaction Qualifications

Akhtar, Sahar
Springer Nature · 2026-09-23 · DOI 10.1007/s10677-026-10583-7

Аннотация

Recently, we have observed a renewed interest, both in popular and academic discussions, in explaining the wrong of discrimination as departures from merit. This paper explores the moral permissibility of considering reaction qualifications (RQs), or qualifications for a job based on the reactions of those who interact with the employee, such as customers, to argue that merit-based approaches—understood in several different ways—do not ultimately seem to provide a satisfactory explanation. I then argue that an alternative view, based in the idea that discrimination is wrong when and because it demeans people, captures our moral intuitions across a wide variety of RQs based in social-group membership, such as race and gender. Central to this view is the focus on avoiding treating people as moral inferiors, suggesting heightened moral attention to comparatively disadvantaged social groups. However, the most plausible interpretation of the view implies neither that it is always wrong to consider RQs disfavoring members of disadvantaged groups nor that it is never wrong to consider RQs disfavoring members of advantaged groups. I defend these claims by examining three cases: W hite in Western N.C. , Christian Professor , and Male Attendant .

Читать у издателя →