Journal of Logic, Language and Information Philosophy

Modal Embedding of the Logic of Analytic Implication

Shin Matsuura
Springer Nature · 2026-05-09 · DOI 10.1007/s10849-026-09470-2

Abstract

Abstract The logic of analytic implication $$\textbf{PAI}$$ PAI developed by William T. Parry is part of a family of relevance logics that exhibits a strong variable-sharing property: $$\phi \rightarrow \psi $$ ϕ → ψ is a theorem only if every variable occurring in $$\psi $$ ψ also occurs in $$\phi $$ ϕ . A demodalized version of $$\textbf{PAI}$$ PAI , known as $$\textbf{DAI}$$ DAI , was formulated in Dunn (1972). Urquhart (1973) further introduced a modal extension of $$\textbf{DAI}$$ DAI , called the logic of analytic implication with necessity, $$\textbf{AIN}$$ AIN . Urquhart conjectured that $$\textbf{PAI}$$ PAI can be embedded into $$\textbf{AIN}$$ AIN by a Gödel-McKinsey-Tarski style translation. This paper provides a proof of this previously unverified conjecture and extends the result to other logics in the neighbourhood of $$\textbf{PAI}$$ PAI . In particular, we show that intuitionistic $$\textbf{PAI}$$ PAI can be embedded into $$\textbf{AIN}$$ AIN by the Gödel-McKinsey-Tarski translation.

Read at publisher →