Journal of Philosophical Logic Philosophy
Counterfactual Worlds
Abstract
Abstract This paper extends Kit Fine’s (2012a, 2012b, 2017a, 2017b, 2017c) truthmaker framework to provide a novel task semantics for tensed counterfactual conditionals. Instead of taking possible worlds to be primitive elements in a model, possible worlds will be defined in terms of states , parthood , tasks , and times where the task relation encodes the possible transitions between states. Rather than invoking primitive relations for similarity or imposition, possible worlds will be compared at a time independent of that time’s past and future where the comparison will be carried out in modal and mereological terms. After reviewing motivations for this approach, I will provide the hyperintensional semantics for counterfactuals that is implemented in the model-checker software along with a unified logic for counterfactual, modal, and tense operators. I will then extend the language to include further tense operators in order to analyze forwards, backwards, and backtracking counterfactuals.