Quantifying in-use storage-time uncertainty for HPLC working standard solutions: a comparative study of three assessment methods
Аннотация
In this study, we systematically evaluated the contribution of storage time to measurement uncertainty for six pharmacopoeial certified reference materials (CRMs) over 180 days under in-use conditions. The experimental protocol—involving repeated sampling from a single storage bottle—was designed to simulate routine laboratory practice; consequently, the quantified uncertainty component reflects the combined effect of chemical degradation and repeated-opening-associated physical changes (e.g., localized evaporation), rather than chemical stability alone. We also compared three uncertainty estimation methods: trend analysis, the range method, and the pooled standard deviation method. We prepared the working solutions according to Chinese Pharmacopoeia specifications and stored them at 2–4 °C in amber glass bottles with PTFE-lined caps. We repeatedly sampled them over time to simulate routine laboratory practice. This experimental design evaluates the in-use stability of the MRC (measurement reference material), which differs fundamentally from the inventory stability protocol recommended by ISO 33405:2024, in which individual sealed vials are opened only once and variability from repeated sampling is eliminated. We identified storage time as the dominant contributor to total measurement uncertainty for all five tested compounds, accounting for 60.0–99.6% of the total variance. The highest contribution (99.6%) was observed for sinapine cyanide sulfonate, a labile alkaloid containing an ester group ( δ t = − 31.70%). Even for stable phenolic compounds such as paeonol and honokiol, which showed no significant degradation trend ( p > 0.05), storage time remained the largest uncertainty component (60.0% and 82.5%, respectively). Among the three methods, the range method appeared the most robust and broadly applicable. It provided conservative estimates (e.g., 18.30% for sinapine cyanide sulfonate vs. 8.76% by pooled SD) without requiring a statistically significant trend. In contrast, the pooled standard deviation method tended to underestimate uncertainty for compounds with monotonic trends, while trend analysis was of limited use for stable compounds. A special case occurred with volatile pulegone, where preparation variability (RSD = 13.26%) dominated over storage effects. This highlights the need for optimized handling protocols for volatile or viscous compounds. Based on these findings, the range method may be a practical choice for routine application. We also suggest that storage time should be included in measurement uncertainty budgets when it is identified as a significant contributor, thereby supporting compliance with ISO/IEC 17025 (clause 7.6).