Scoreability burden in multi-round AQUACHECK water-chemistry proficiency testing: an analyte–matrix–method assessment-burden atlas from 18 PT rounds

High Energy Chemistry · Springer Nature · 2026-11-18 · DOI: 10.1007/s00769-026-01749-y

Аннотация

Proficiency testing (PT) in water chemistry is commonly interpreted through z-score performance classifications, but multi-round schemes also contain assessment constraints that modify or prevent ordinary direct scoring. This retrospective study analysed 27,367 core-water assessment records from 18 LGC AQUACHECK rounds and 1,294 laboratories. A cell was defined as one PT round × analyte × matrix-group × harmonized method-group combination. Scoreability-limited assessment was defined as comment-refined z′ use or no-score/information-only status and comprised 961 records (3.5 %); low-participant support was retained separately as a participant-support component of the Assessment Burden Index (ABI). ABI equally combines warning-range, unacceptable-range, z′-use, no-score/information-only, and low-participant proportions. Of 1,873 cells, 795 met the primary pragmatic support rule of n ≥ 10. The highest support-qualified ABI was 26.0, and all 12 displayed high-burden cells had 100 % z′ use; because z′ is one of five equally weighted components, this contributes a structural 20 ABI points. Alternative support thresholds changed exact high-cell membership. ABI is an optional retrospective monitoring layer for locating and decomposing assessment burden, rather than a replacement PT score or laboratory competence criterion.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи