The Battlefield of Indeterminate Causation and its Additivity

Contemporary Family Therapy · Springer Nature · 2026-09-24 · DOI: 10.1007/s12136-026-00709-y

Аннотация

A number of philosophers have argued that causation can be indeterminate, particularly in cases of causation by omission such as Sartorio’s Battlefield . In Battlefield , an inaction is followed by the deaths of three soldiers, though had the inaction not occurred, one and only one soldier would have been saved. Some philosophers claim that with respect to any particular soldier’s death, it is indeterminate whether the inaction caused that death despite its being false that the inaction caused all three deaths. One objection to this “indeterminist option” is that if indeterminate causation is additive, then since it is indeterminate whether the inaction caused each particular death, it should be indeterminate whether the inaction caused all three deaths. But it is false that the inaction caused all the deaths. I will argue that there are restrictions built into the additivity of indeterminate causation that mean that this objection fails.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи