Asian Journal of Business Ethics Philosophy
From the regulated “We” to the vulnerable “Thou”: translating Levinas for governance in an emerging economy
Abstract
This study examines how legal and regulatory frameworks in emerging economies, with a particular focus on Vietnam, govern corporate responsibility and the ethical limits of business and human rights (BHR) governance. We argue that while the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs) provide an essential governance framework for corporate responsibility, the implementation of human rights due diligence inevitably depends upon procedural mechanisms that cannot, by themselves, fully capture the ethical responsiveness required by the vulnerability of affected stakeholders. By analyzing Vietnam’s legal framework, regulatory reforms, and major corporate scandals, we identify a persistent gap between regulatory intent and ethical outcomes, showing how governance tends to center organizational accountability while diffusing responsibility away from vulnerable groups. To explain this gap, we mobilize Levinasian ethics as a theoretical intervention, revealing a blind spot in contemporary BHR governance: the translation of ethical responsibility into procedural forms that can obscure vulnerability and sideline rightsholders. Theoretically, we introduce a Levinasian relational ethics lens that complements existing BHR governance by illuminating the ethical limits of procedural approaches to human rights due diligence. Empirically, we undertake a comparative analysis of selected governance instruments across the United States, China, and Vietnam to examine how different institutional arrangement’s structure responsibility toward vulnerable stakeholders. Finally, we propose an empathy duty as a normative governance principle that guides the interpretation and implementation of existing legal and governance obligations, thereby strengthening the ethical orientation of BHR governance through continuous responsiveness to vulnerable stakeholders.