Ethical Theory and Moral Practice Философия

The Uptake Problem and Beyond: Rethinking Belief Formation in Radical Political Realism

Tang, Yun
Springer Nature · 2026-10-29 · DOI 10.1007/s10677-026-10588-2

Аннотация

This paper argues that, although radical realist ideology critique has persuasively shown how ethical norms can function as vehicles of ideological legitimation, its account of belief formation remains incomplete. It is not enough to acknowledge that the public circulation of a norm, or outward conformity to it, does not entail belief. Radical realism must also explain how we can determine whether a power-shaped norm has actually been taken up by agents as a reason for accepting or maintaining a particular belief. This diagnostic difficulty constitutes what the paper terms the uptake problem. Unless ideology critique can distinguish genuine uptake from strategic conformity, retrospective rationalization, and acceptance grounded in independent reasons, it risks identifying potentially ideological processes without being able to establish that any particular belief is ideological. In response, this paper proposes an uptake-sensitive framework for examining the practical conditions under which norms acquire traction in agents’ beliefs. By treating uptake as graded rather than as an all-or-nothing psychological event, the paper extends radical realism with a more precise and agent-sensitive account of how ideology critique can diagnose the success, partial success, or failure of power-shaped norms in becoming reasons for belief.

Читать у издателя →