Asian Journal of Philosophy Philosophy

On remembering remembering

Sakuragi, Shin
Springer Nature · 2026-11-03 · DOI 10.1007/s44204-026-00449-1

Abstract

Experiences of remembering may be remembered later. This paper explores how such cases of higher-order remembering are to be explained in different theoretical frameworks in philosophy of memory. In the first part of this paper, I outline two challenges, the limit problem and the transparency problem, posed by higher-order remembering, and survey potential solutions from the two major theories of successful episodic remembering, alethism and authenticism. In the second part, I focus on the Bergsonian framework (the B/H picture) recently proposed by Yasushi Hirai. Under the B/H picture, the representational content of second-order remembering is reconstructed independently of its first-order “genuine memory.” For this reason, I argue that the B/H picture faces a significant challenge in explaining how we re-remember a past experience without misidentifying it among other similar experiences. The difficulty suggests that any adequate theory of episodic memory must incorporate an account of how we re-remember past episodes by somewhat reliably keeping track of the identity of remembered episodes.

Read at publisher →