Excluding the low performers: the interaction of supervisor bottom-line mentality and moral relativism in supervisor incivility

Journal of World Prehistory · Springer Nature · 2026-09-09 · DOI: 10.1007/s10869-026-10150-y

Аннотация

This research contributes to understanding why supervisors direct incivility toward some subordinates but not others by examining the contingent role of perceived subordinate performance. Grounded in organizational justice and moral exclusion theory, we conceptualize supervisor incivility as a form of interactional injustice that may arise when supervisors place subordinates perceived as low-performing outside their “scope of justice.” We propose a contingency model in which the relationship between perceived subordinate performance and supervisor incivility depends jointly on supervisor bottom-line mentality (BLM) and moral relativism. BLM represents a results-oriented mindset that prioritizes goal attainment over relational concerns, whereas moral relativism is a flexible moral orientation according to which ethical standards are viewed as context-dependent. We tested this theoretical logic across two complementary studies: a multi-source, time-lagged field study and a scenario experiment. The results were consistent with the proposed three-way interaction. Specifically, incivility toward low-performing subordinates was most pronounced when moral relativism was high, and either supervisor BLM was strong or bottom-line climate cues were salient. These findings highlight the joint role of motivational and moral conditions in shaping when perceived low performance is associated with uncivil supervisory treatment. We discuss the theoretical and practical implications of these findings.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи