Age bias in resume screening: are HR professionals more biased than ChatGPT?
Аннотация
Organizations face the dual challenge of an aging workforce and the growing use of artificial intelligence (AI) in personnel selection, urging selection procedures that are both efficient and age-inclusive. Yet it remains unclear whether AI makes hiring decisions less susceptible to age bias than human decision-makers. Across two studies, we compared how HR professionals and ChatGPT-5.4 evaluated younger and older job applicants. We also examined whether these evaluations depended on applicants’ gender and job age-type. When applicants were clearly qualified (study 1), ChatGPT-5.4 ( N = 1600) rated older applicants less favorably than younger applicants, whereas HR professionals ( N = 398) did not show this age bias. When applicants’ qualifications were more ambiguous (study 2), both ChatGPT-5.4 ( N = 1600) and HR professionals ( N = 402) evaluated older applicants less favorably. Under these more ambiguous conditions, ChatGPT-5.4 also took into account applicant gender and job age-type, showing more age bias for men and in young-typed jobs. Overall, ChatGPT-5.4 showed more consistent evidence of an age penalty than HR professionals, but the age bias depends on applicant qualifications. We recommend combining AI‑assisted screening with human oversight to support age‑inclusive hiring.