Acta Biotheoretica Philosophy

Measuring Biological Processes, Counting Biological Individuals, and the Botanical Conception of the Organism

Yilmaz Silverman, Özlem
Springer Nature · 2026-09-16 · DOI 10.1007/s10441-026-09542-7

Abstract

Biological individuality constitutes a broad and continuously expanding literature in philosophy of biology. The two new books reviewed here offer detailed examinations of kinds of individual (Clarke) and the organism (Baedke). While it is beyond the limits of this essay to settle whether “biological individuals” means organisms only or not, I briefly describe these concepts and talk about how they are examined in the two books. Looking into scientific practices is crucial for understanding the concepts of biological individuality and organism. I particularly draw on Clarke’s work to investigate the initial stages of research processes and present my own argument pointing to an attitude difference that involves conceptualizing different kinds of individuals: either having measurement-related considerations first or counting-related considerations first. I also argue for the importance of looking into plant sciences (including plant stress research) and their history for researching the conceptual challenges faced by organism-centered biology that Baedke points out. Examining practices in botany and history of botany are indispensable for understanding biological individuals and the organism.

Read at publisher →