ICT use and academic performance in top-performing Asian educational systems: A multilevel latent profile analysis of students and schools
Аннотация
This study investigated the relationship between information and communication technology (ICT) use and academic performance across Hong Kong, Macao, Chinese Taipei, Japan, South Korea, and Singapore. Utilizing PISA 2022 data ( N = 33,867), a multilevel latent profile analysis was conducted to identify ICT use profiles and their correlations with academic performance. At the student level, distinct use profiles were identified: “very low” (found only in Japan), “low,” “normal,” and “high.” In five systems, students with normal ICT use achieved the highest performance. In South Korea alone, students with high ICT use did not differ significantly from those with normal ICT use. At the school level, while four systems (Hong Kong, Macao, Taipei, and Singapore) displayed a binary structure (schools with normal ICT use and low ICT use), their relationship with academic performance varied significantly. In Hong Kong and Taipei, schools with normal ICT use outperformed those with low ICT use. In Macao, different schools exhibited different advantaged subjects. In Singapore, there were no significant differences between schools with different ICT use. Schools in South Korea exhibited different profiles (rich, normal and poor ICT use), highlighting significant disparities in digital equity where schools with rich ICT use outperformed others. Conversely, Japan presented a polarized context in which schools with poor ICT use paradoxically outperformed normal schools in mathematics. The study suggests that policymakers must address specific system needs.