Scientific misconduct in contemporary research: a systematic review with an integrated framework for detection and prevention

Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery · Springer Nature · 2026-11-16 · DOI: 10.1007/s43538-026-00987-5

Аннотация

Objective Scientific misconduct remains a significant threat to the integrity of scientific communication. Although numerous studies have been conducted on its types and consequences, there is still a lack of comprehensive knowledge that integrates its underlying causes, detection mechanisms, and prevention strategies. This review aims to systematically synthesize existing literature on scientific misconduct in an attempt to develop a conceptual model that integrates all its underlying causes, detection mechanisms, and prevention strategies. Methods An extensive literature search was carried out in various databases like PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar for articles published between 1987 and 2026. The keywords used for searching were “scientific misconduct,” “research integrity,” “plagiarism,” “data fabrication,” and “publication ethics.” The articles were selected according to specific criteria and were critically analyzed. Results The findings suggest that the occurrence of scientific misconduct is the result of complex interactions between individual pressures, institutional weaknesses, and system-wide influences, including the "publish or perish" ethos. Although the more conventional techniques of detection, including peer review and plagiarism detection tools, are essential, the new challenges posed by AI-generated material, paper mills, and image manipulation demand more sophisticated techniques. There are also gaps in the standardization and enforcement worldwide. Conclusion This review offers a thorough synthesis of the concept of scientific misconduct and proposes an integrated framework to improve the understanding of the underlying causes and controlling mechanisms of misconduct in research. Enhancing research integrity is crucial and calls for collaborative efforts at individual, organizational, and policy levels, along with the implementation of emerging technological solutions. Graphical abstract

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи