The double-edged sword effect of perceived star employees on leaders: a cognitive appraisal theory of stress perspective
Аннотация
Leaders serve as critical gatekeepers in transforming human capital into organizational advantage. Yet, managing star employees presents a distinctive leadership dilemma, as these individuals simultaneously function as “Red Giants” that generate high performance and “Black Holes” that consume disproportionate organizational resources. Although prior research has extensively examined star employees themselves, little is known about the cognitive processes underlying leaders’ divergent behavioral responses to these high-stakes actors. Drawing on a leader-centric perspective and the cognitive appraisal theory of stress, this study examines how and why leaders adjust their behavioral strategies when interacting with stars. Drawing on a temporally separated research design and data collected from 255 leader-employee dyads, this study demonstrates that leaders form dual cognitive appraisals in response to star employees. Specifically, perceived star employees trigger leaders’ challenge appraisals and facilitate adaptive work reflection; meanwhile, they induce threat appraisals and further promote leaders’ maladaptive exploitative leadership behaviors. Furthermore, leaders’ moral identity serves as an important cognitive filter that shapes the relative strength of these appraisals and the corresponding indirect effects on leader behaviors. By centering on leaders’ cognitive processing, this research advances understanding of the complex psychological mechanisms involved in managing high-performing talent.