Negotiating competing religious–secular hegemonies: in-betweenness among Gray Zone youth in Turkey
Abstract
This article examines how young adults in contemporary Turkey negotiate religious and secular normative orders and how these negotiations are articulated as in-betweenness. Drawing on 30 semi-structured interviews conducted between 2022 and 2024 with participants recruited through and around Gray Zone ( Gri Bölge ), an online youth initiative on X, the article analyzes experiences of moral pressure, exclusion, partial belonging, and critical attachment across family life, religious communities, peer networks, educational settings, and digital environments. In-betweenness is conceptualized not as a midpoint between religiosity and secularity but as a relational tension among normative attachment, social belonging, and everyday conduct. Hegemony is used to identify the wider social authority through which particular religious or secular norms become standards for legitimate ways of believing, living, and belonging, without implying that religious and secular forms of power have held the same institutional reach or historical authority. Within this strategically selected sample, religious participants articulated in-betweenness more extensively, often while maintaining strong commitments to Islam but negotiating restrictive interpretations and moral expectations within religious milieus as well as exclusionary secular expectations in other settings. Secular participants more often retained secularity as a preferred normative framework even when criticizing exclusionary secular milieus. The analysis further develops mahallesizlik (neighborhoodlessness) as a spatial, relational, and symbolic expression of partial and contested belonging.