Technologies of intention: piety, productivity, and Muslim women in Singapore
Abstract
Existing scholarship on Islamic piety often treats actions ( amal ) and intentions ( niyyah ) as aligned and mutually reinforcing. This paper offers an alternative view: in Singapore’s hyper-capitalist and technocratic context, these domains can become separated. Drawing on ethnographic research with middle-class professional Muslim women, I argue that the state’s survivalist ethos, which often links productivity to citizenship and moral worth, creates conditions in which the demands of scripturalist piety and professional productivity frequently come into tension. In response, my interlocutors increasingly privilege niyyah (intention) over amal (visible practice) as a means of negotiating competing ethical demands. Yet this inward turn generates its own paradox: in critiquing visible religiosity as commodified or performative (exemplified by “ hijabster ” culture), my interlocutors claim a more authentic form of piety through the very act of distinguishing themselves from others. The reorientation toward niyyah thus both resists and reproduces the logic of competitive distinction it seeks to escape, recasting interiority itself as a site of moral evaluation and judgment.