Archiving silence: a diagnostic framework for gendered epistemic exclusion in environmental recordkeeping
Аннотация
The more visible women become in environmental records, the more thoroughly their epistemic authority can be foreclosed. This paradox, in which archival inclusion operates as a medium of epistemic exclusion, structures the relationship between gender and environmental recordkeeping across institutional contexts. Disaster databases, climate adaptation records, and environmental impact assessments increasingly claim to incorporate gender, yet women routinely appear in these documentary systems as data points and beneficiaries rather than as knowledge-producing subjects whose frameworks might reshape the archival categories through which environmental harm is documented. This article brings feminist epistemology and postcolonial ecocriticism into dialogue with archival theory to develop a diagnostic framework, the spectrum of silencing, identifying three mechanisms through which environmental recordkeeping produces gendered epistemic exclusion: metric backgrounding (appraisal operations that convert embodied subjects into interchangeable data points, foreclosing questions of differential accountability), testimonial capture (descriptive frameworks that absorb embodied testimony into dominant registers, producing testimonial smothering), and infrastructural erasure (the slow erosion of material conditions for knowledge transmission, rendering place-based knowledge unarchivable). The framework is tested through a comparative close reading of four poems spanning three continents, treated as diagnostic sites where the representational operations underlying archival practice become visible with concentrated formal clarity. The article contributes to critical archival studies by specifying how environmental records systems actively produce gendered epistemic hierarchies rather than passively reflecting them, and proposes counter-strategies calibrated to each mechanism, including revised appraisal criteria, community-controlled documentation, and participatory recordkeeping.