Digital government as historical recoding: path dependence and recordkeeping continuity in Turkey
Аннотация
This article examines how recordkeeping infrastructures mediate institutional continuity across the Ottoman, Republican and digital periods in Turkey. It asks how successive systems for creating, organising and mobilising authoritative records have enabled administrative logics to persist while their material and technological forms changed. The study combines historical institutionalism with records continuum scholarship and draws on qualitative analysis of a 427-item corpus of archival, legislative and digital-governance documents. The analysis identifies four analytical patterns: centralised coordination, registry-based administration, state-led modernisation and data-mediated governance. The first three recur across periods to varying degrees, whereas data-mediated governance becomes most visible in the contemporary digital period. Representative documentary examples make the basis of these interpretations explicit. Ottoman Mühimme registers connected inscription with central oversight; Republican legislation and development plans recodified administrative authority in statutory and planning records; and MERNİS (the Central Population Administration System) and TAKBİS (the Land Registry and Cadastre Information System) carried established registration functions into electronic form, while the e-Devlet Kapısı (Turkey’s e-government gateway) connects services and information across institutions. A reading of the official instructions shows which recordkeeping properties they address for MERNİS (electronic signature, linkage of scanned documents, permanent retention of registers, restricted access and correction) and where they are silent. These examples support an interpretation of continuity through layering and conversion, but do not establish an unbroken or exclusively endogenous trajectory. The article contributes to archival scholarship by treating two registry systems, MERNİS and TAKBİS, not only as service-delivery technologies but also as recordkeeping infrastructures that carry established registers into electronic form, and by treating the e-Devlet Kapısı as an exchange layer through which institutions share records held elsewhere. “Historical recoding” denotes the reconfiguration of inherited recordkeeping and administrative logics within new infrastructures. The single-country, interpretive design limits causal and statistical generalisation; the findings instead offer a historically grounded account of how recordkeeping arrangements can condition digital state formation.