Continental Philosophy Review Философия
Presence and transcendence beyond metaphysics: reinterpreting Mulla Ṣadrā’s ontology through Marion’s phenomenology of givenness
Аннотация
This article reinterprets Mulla Ṣadrā’s (d. 1640) ontology of existence through the lens of Jean-Luc Marion’s phenomenology of givenness in order to propose a constructive “onto-phenomenology of manifestation.” It pursues a twofold aim. First, it offers a comparative analysis that reconstructs structural convergences and divergences between Ṣadrā’s graded ontology of wujūd and Marion’s account of saturated phenomena, donation, and the gifted subject (l’adonné, “the one to whom something is given”). Second, on the basis of this comparison, it advances a constructive synthesis that integrates ontological and phenomenological approaches to manifestation. Methodologically, the article justifies its focus on the theme of presence and manifestation—rather than, for instance, love or temporality—because both thinkers explicitly wrestle with how transcendence discloses itself in and as presence without being reduced to conceptual or ontic categories. While other comparative axes would be possible, presence functions as a shared hinge between ontology and phenomenology, and thus provides a coherent criterion for thematic selection. Rather than approaching the two thinkers through merely historical comparison, the study stages a systematic dialogue between Ṣadrā’s doctrines of the primacy and gradation of existence, substantial motion, and knowledge by presence (ʿilm ḥuḍūrī, literally “knowledge through being-present”) and Marion’s reduction to givenness, theory of saturated phenomena, and reconfiguration of subjectivity. Both thinkers share the intuition that transcendence is disclosed in and as presence rather than through conceptual determination, yet they diverge sharply regarding the status of being, the limits of conceptuality, and the role of subjectivity. The article proceeds in three movements. First, it reconstructs Ṣadrā’s ontology of manifestation. Second, it outlines Marion’s phenomenology of givenness and the debates surrounding it, including criticisms of the “theological turn.” Third, it offers a thematic comparison focused on ontology and givenness, presence and excess, and subjectivity and receptivity, explicitly addressing the asymmetry between Ṣadrā’s theological ontology and Marion’s methodological bracketing of theology. Building on these analyses, the article then proposes an onto-phenomenology of manifestation and illustrates its usefulness through two concrete case-studies: mystical experience and interfaith dialogue. The project is primarily descriptive–constructive: it does not prescribe a single theological position, but it does articulate a normative ethos of receptive presence.