Physical, virtual, and hybrid programming modalities in early childhood education: a randomized controlled study of computational thinking and programming behaviors
Аннотация
Young children are at a crucial period for computational thinking (CT) development. In recent years, different programming modalities, such as physical, virtual, and hybrid programming, have been introduced to promote young children’s CT. However, empirical evidence of which programming modalities are more effective in terms of promoting young children’s CT remains scarce. Hence, we conducted a randomized controlled trial to compare the effects of physical, virtual, and hybrid programming on young children’s CT and programming behaviors. Participants included 168 children aged 5–7, who were randomly allocated to the physical, virtual, or hybrid programming groups. Quantitative analyses indicated that children in the physical, virtual, and hybrid programming groups demonstrated significant improvements in CT following the 8-week intervention. Notably, children in the physical programming group showed greater improvements in CT than those in the virtual and hybrid programming groups, whereas no significant difference was found between the virtual and hybrid groups. Qualitative analyses revealed distinct behavioral patterns across modalities, while also showing that each modality can support children’s core programming processes. This study can inform educators and researchers when selecting appropriate programming modalities for promoting young children’s CT.