Anatomy of risk under biased expectations and disagreement

GZ - Psychologie · Springer Nature · 2026-08-07 · DOI: 10.1007/s10203-026-00603-7

Аннотация

Speculative variance in financial markets is usually traced to disagreement about expected returns. This paper asks whether speculation can arise instead from how traders perceive the covariance between asset returns and the background risks they hedge, a question left open by models built on mean disagreement alone. In a continuous-time economy with rational and non-rational traders, a single bias parameter, motivated by the diagnostic expectations literature, distorts how non-rational traders perceive the covariance between asset returns and the background risks they hedge. When the bias is positive and rational traders stand ready to take the other side of the resulting mispricing, speculative variance remains strictly positive even though all traders agree on expected returns. This variance is a closed-form quadratic in the bias, so a stochastic bias admits an explicit law of motion, and ordinary fluctuations push long-run average risk above the constant-bias benchmark. Financial innovation widens the effect, since each fresh hedging instrument adds a dimension along which covariance can be misjudged, and the speculation it produces looks like hedging demand rather than the volume-heavy trading of disagreement. The same mechanism, sustained by limited arbitrage capital, generates an endogenous price correction and volatility surge once sentiment reverses. Covariance misperception therefore warrants attention as a quiet source of systemic fragility.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи