Beyond the spots: Expanding photo-identification in rays through a review and validation of marbled patterning
Аннотация
Photo-identification, which involves the recognition of individuals based on their natural markings, has become an increasingly valuable tool for studying elasmobranchs, offering a non-invasive alternative to traditional tagging methods. Despite this, its application in ray research remains limited and biased towards a small number of species. Here, we provide a review and synthesis of all published studies on ray photo-identification to evaluate the species studied, marking types, geographic distribution, and analytical tools applied. Analysis of 58 studies revealed pronounced taxonomic and some geographic biases, a near-exclusive reliance on spot-based markings, and limited validation of alternative pattern types, despite the wide diversity of patterning exhibited by rays. Guided by these findings, we present a case study on the blue stingray Dasyatis chrysonota to assess whether its marbled dorsal patterning could be used for individual identification. Using manual matching, existing photo-ID software, and a semi-automated identification system using Miew-ID-msv3 ( Raydar ), we demonstrate that marbled patterns are highly individualistic and stable over time. Manual identification achieved near-perfect accuracy but was labour-intensive, whereas Raydar provided strong discriminatory performance with substantially improved processing efficiency. Spot-based software performed poorly on marbled patterning, highlighting the importance of selecting analytical tools appropriate to marking type. Together, these results demonstrate that photo-identification in rays is not limited to spot-based patterning and can be extended to species with marbled patterning, with broader implications for other taxa with similar patterning. Finally, methodological recommendations are provided, including species-specific pattern validation, standardised image collection, and hybrid manual–automated workflows, to support the reliable and scalable application of photo-identification across diverse ray species and environments.