Beyond competing drivers: Integrating ecology, governance and conservation for Himalayan oak conservation

Developmental Biology Advances · Springer Nature · 2026-11-18 · DOI: 10.1007/s10531-026-03533-3

Аннотация

The recent commentary by Thadani (2026) on the oak-pine dynamics (Chowdhary et al. 2026) has rejuvenated the discussion on the drivers of oak ( Quercus leucotrichophora ) decline and chir pine ( Pinus roxburghii ) expansion in the Western Himalaya. While Chowdhary et al. (2026) emphasized climate change and associated ecological mechanisms, Thadani (2026) highlighted chronic anthropogenic disturbance and recurrent fire as the predominant drivers of forest transition. This commentary argues that framing this debate around competing explanations risks oversimplifying a complex socio-ecological system. It revisits four aspects that need further consideration. First, anthropogenic disturbances in the Himalaya are evolving from localised to landscape-level. Second, predictions of oak resilience are based solely on contrasting hydraulic strategies, which overlook the interaction of plant ecophysiology with disturbance history, which may influence species responses to climatic stress. Third, conservation-oriented ecological research should distinguish between the implementation of a policy, its intended aims, and its ecological outcomes. The last part of the commentary aims to bridge the gap between ecological research and conservation through governance. This paper argues that ecological mechanisms alone cannot fully explain the ongoing oak-pine transitions in Himalayan states without considering how governance influences ecosystem trajectories. The commentary highlights the need to integrate governance into conservation-oriented ecological research.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи