Continental Philosophy Review Philosophy
On motivation. A phenomenological argument for the intelligibility and non-alienation of motivating reasons
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to think about motivation in order to recognize its rational legitimacy in the description and explanation of human beliefs and behaviors. To this end, we make use of Edmund Husserl’s phenomenology and ideas from contemporary epistemology. We propose a three-step approach. First, we seek a concept of intelligibility by clarifying the intentional structure of motivation: the distinction between intentional reference and real reference will be fundamental. Second, we aim to demonstrate that motivating reasons cannot be reduced to empirical facts. Third, we explore the extent to which motivating reasons—rather than merely causal explanations—are essential to prevent the individual from becoming alienated from the reasons underlying their actions and beliefs, as well as to prevent the resulting depersonalization.