When leader perfectionism works and when it does not: the role of leader vision in shaping follower outcomes
Аннотация
Leader perfectionism is receiving increasing research attention, yet scholars continue to debate whether, when, and how it enhances or undermines follower performance. Adopting a meaning-centric perspective, we theorize that leader vision—a leader-originated and follower-perceived meaning cue—conditions whether leader perfectionism is associated with follower task reflexivity or ego depletion, which in turn implicates follower performance. Through a behavioral experiment involving 412 participants completing a work task (study 1) and a three-wave field study involving 72 supervisors and 280 employees (study 2), we consistently found that leader perfectionism was positively associated with follower task reflexivity when leader vision was strong. In study 2, task reflexivity further accounted for a positive conditional indirect association between leader perfectionism and follower job performance. In study 1, the effect of leader perfectionism on follower ego depletion was stronger when leader vision was weak, but this moderating effect was not replicated in study 2; although ego depletion was negatively related to follower performance, the corresponding conditional indirect effect was not supported. Overall, the findings of the two studies indicate that leader vision shapes how leader perfectionism is experienced by followers, revealing the circumstances under which this leader trait functions as a catalyst versus a constraint in follower performance. We discuss the implications of the findings for both theory and practice.