The alignment of sacred forests with the concept of other effective area-based conservation measures
Аннотация
Sacred natural sites, while not always formally recognised as protected areas, can protect biodiversity via the customs and practices that prohibit exploitation for spiritual reasons. As such, these sites may align with the concept of other effective area-based conservation measures (OECMs), which recognise places that protect biodiversity outside formal protected areas. Sacred forests and groves are one type of sacred natural site that have had their biodiversity outcomes studied, providing evidence with which to assess their potential to be OECMs. Here, we reviewed studies that measured biodiversity in sacred forests, and asked whether sites could meet the criteria to be OECMs by providing positive and sustained outcomes for biodiversity, along with the management and governance structures required for sites to be OECMs. Most studies pointed to sacred forests containing important biodiversity, with over half reporting they supported intact native ecosystems. Where an impact evaluation framework was used to assess sacred forests relative to other land uses, the type of counterfactual used to assess biodiversity outcomes was important, with poorer performance reported when sacred forests were compared to protected areas. Outcomes were also poorer if monitored over time rather than at a single time point. Sites were subject to a range of anthropogenic pressures but had a range of restrictions in place to mitigate those pressures. Overall, we found that sacred forests could align well with the concept of OECMs but may need support to ensure they can maintain positive outcomes over time, especially if threats increase outside these sites.