International Journal for Philosophy of Religion Philosophy

Cognitivism about religious belief in later Wittgenstein

Alois Pichler, Sebastian Sunday Grève
Springer Nature · 2024-12-09 · DOI 10.1007/s11153-024-09933-1

Abstract

Abstract Wittgensteinian philosophy of religion has traditionally been grounded in non-cognitivism about religious belief. This paper shows that the Wittgensteinian tradition has wrongly neglected a significant movement towards cognitivism in Wittgenstein’s later writings. The argument proceeds on the basis of two main claims. First, Wittgenstein’s mature philosophy, as expressed in his Philosophical Investigations , clearly favours cognitivism over non-cognitivism with regard to certain linguistic facts about ordinary religious discourse. Second, during the last decade of his life Wittgenstein’s view of religious belief actually underwent a significant shift in the direction of cognitivism, which finds its most striking expression in the analogy he draws to the ‘honest religious thinker’.

Read at publisher →