A probabilistic classification framework for laboratory performance evaluation in mycotoxin proficiency testing: integrating z -scores, ζ-scores and measurement uncertainty

High Energy Chemistry · Springer Nature · 2026-09-05 · DOI: 10.1007/s00769-026-01738-1

Аннотация

Proficiency testing (PT) programmes in mycotoxin analysis predominantly rely on the z -score for participant performance evaluation, which does not incorporate the laboratory's reported measurement uncertainty. In this study, 2,538 results from 15 mycotoxin PT rounds conducted between 2020 and 2025 were analysed using a binary classification framework comprising 12 probability categories (P1 to P12), based on the combined evaluation of z -scores, ζ-scores, and measurement uncertainty adequacy. The analysis revealed that a substantial proportion of results classified as satisfactory under z -score-only evaluation were reclassified as unsatisfactory when the ζ-score was applied, showing that z -score-only assessment may overlook results for which the observed deviation is inconsistent with the participant-reported measurement uncertainty. Measurement uncertainty underestimation was markedly more prevalent than overestimation, and the mathematically constrained P6 category and the mathematically excluded P8 category were not observed in the dataset. These findings support consideration of ζ-score evaluation alongside structured measurement uncertainty assessment in mycotoxin PT programmes, particularly in regulatory contexts where performance classifications may inform accreditation and regulatory oversight.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи