A personalized consensus model for safety-oriented emergency decision-making with heterogeneous experts
Аннотация
Emergency decision-making in safety-critical situations is constrained by time pressure, incomplete information, and differences in expert judgment and social influence. These conditions make timely agreement difficult while repeated preference revision may impose a burden. This study develops a personalized consensus model based on distributed linguistic preference relations and personalized numerical scales. The model represents human factors through hesitant judgments, expert-specific numerical semantics, preference distribution uncertainty, evaluative extremity, judgment consistency, and dynamic relational influence. A three-way mechanism assigns state-dependent feedback according to each expert’s current consensus state. The three treatments are retention of the current personalized numerical scale and its induced additive preference relation, eligibility for an update to the personalized numerical scale, and withdrawal with influence delegation. The procedure gives priority to the first feedback round in which the consensus target is reached and then selects the feedback result with the smallest measure of preference revision in that round. In a computational application set in the context of a publicly reported port accident, the consensus target is reached after one feedback round. Sensitivity analysis shows that the lower individual consensus threshold affects expert participation, whereas the group consensus target affects the required preference revision and may change the leading alternative. The final result remains unchanged across the tested values of the upper individual consensus threshold. A structural comparison distinguishes the proposed feedback structure from related consensus approaches.