University Reputation in the Making: Expert-Informed Refinement of a Literature-Derived Framework Through an international Delphi Study

Fernández-Gubieda, Santiago, Gutiérrez-García, Elena, Bello, Oihane
Corporate Reputation Review · Springer Nature · 2026-10-16 · DOI: 10.1057/s41299-026-00283-4

Аннотация

This study examines how an international expert panel assessed and refined a literature-derived conceptualisation of university reputation, focusing on construct boundaries, stakeholder importance, contested management assumptions and preliminary governance implications. A two-round Delphi consultation was conducted in 2021 with 21 experts from 13 countries and four professional profiles, combining 1–7 ratings, stakeholder rankings and open responses. Agreement, dispersion and stability are reported descriptively using item-specific denominators. Experts supported the revised working definition and most institutional, stakeholder and contextual elements, but their comments challenged treating these as equivalent parts of reputation. The revised account separates institutional antecedents and signals from stakeholder-specific evaluation and subsequent outcomes. Stakeholder rankings were highly stable in the matched 19-participant comparison (Spearman ρ = 0.999), whereas views on ‘reputation management’ showed persistent dispersion. Governance implications were positively rated but remain preliminary and causally indeterminate. The article uses Delphi evidence to move from a literature-derived taxonomy to an expert-informed process model, clarifying the distinct roles of institutional antecedents, signals, stakeholder evaluators, context, reputational evaluation, outcomes and feedback. Universities should focus on institutional quality, conduct, stakeholder experience and credible signals rather than assume that stakeholder evaluations can be controlled directly. Relative to the authors’ 2025 systematic review, the study contributes a transparent expert stress-test of the literature-derived framework, showing which elements were retained, refined, reclassified or contested and using those patterns to motivate a post-Delphi process specification. The expert panel was not a representative stakeholder sample, no a priori numerical consensus criterion was used, and the proposed process relationships require subsequent empirical testing.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи