Feedback-enabled digital textbook versus time-matched printed practice for introductory echocardiography learning: a randomized educational trial

Lu, Chang, Zhang, Hui-Xia, Zhang, Hang, Jia, Lan-Ting, Sun, Lv-Ping, Song, Jia-Lin, Huang, He-Jing
BMC Medical Education · Springer Nature · 2026-11-21 · DOI: 10.1186/s12909-026-10900-9

Аннотация

Background We evaluated whether classroom-embedded practice supported by a feedback-enabled digital textbook could improve learning outcomes in introductory echocardiography compared with time-matched printed practice without immediate feedback. Methods In this single-center randomized educational trial, 120 undergraduates without prior formal cardiac ultrasound training were allocated 1:1 to digital-textbook or printed-materials practice (n = 60 each). The groups attended separate 120-min classes on consecutive mornings, taught by the same instructor with matched content, structure, and three 15-min practice blocks. Digital practice included immediate item-level feedback, brief explanations, and targeted post-item animations or videos; printed practice used thematically matched static exercises without immediate feedback. Both groups received the same script-based debriefing with error correction. The primary outcome was immediate post-test knowledge (0–20), analyzed by analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) adjusted for foundational pre-test knowledge (0–10). Secondary outcomes were assessor-blinded apical four-chamber (A4C) image interpretation on a single-station mini objective structured clinical examination (mini-OSCE; 0–10) and day 7 knowledge (0–10). The study received ethics approval, and all participants provided written informed consent. Results All 120 participants completed all assessments. The adjusted immediate knowledge difference favored the digital-textbook group by 2.21 points (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.41–3.02; P < 0.001). The point estimate exceeded the prespecified 2-point educational benchmark, while the CI included differences below and above it. The digital-textbook group also had higher A4C image-interpretation mini-OSCE scores (median [interquartile range, IQR], 7.00 [6.13–8.00] vs 5.00 [5.00–6.50]) and day 7 knowledge scores (median [IQR], 7.50 [5.00–8.00] vs 5.00 [4.00–7.00]; both P < 0.001). Conclusions Within matched scheduled classroom time, digital-textbook practice was associated with higher immediate and day 7 knowledge scores and higher scores on a single-station A4C image-interpretation mini-OSCE. The study evaluated the complete practice approach; unmeasured session-related factors may have contributed to the observed differences. These findings inform the evaluation and selection of complete practice resources for introductory echocardiography. Trial registration Clinical trial number: not applicable. This study was an educational randomized trial evaluating learning outcomes rather than health outcomes and was therefore not registered in a clinical trial registry.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи