This study examines how MiFID II’s mandatory elicitation of retail investors’ sustainability preferences is reflected in advisory recommendations and actual investment behavior. Using a comprehensive real-world dataset covering 18,250 advisory meetings at a German savings bank, we analyze how clients’ stated environmental, social, and governance (ESG) preferences relate to both the advice they receive and the investments they subsequently implement. Across the transition from a voluntary to a mandatory elicitation regime, the share of clients reporting sustainability preferences declined markedly, and stated preferences translated only weakly into observable investment decisions. Our findings reveal a gap between regulatory design and client engagement, highlighting challenges in operationalizing sustainability preferences. We discuss these results alongside ESMA stakeholder feedback and propose practical improvements to strengthen the alignment between preference elicitation, advice, and implementation.
Brühl, Volker, Radetzky, Marie-Therèse, Stolper, Oscar A. Shaping the compass? How sustainability preference elicitation guides investor demand. // Journal of Business Economics. – 2026. – DOI: 10.1007/s11573-026-01282-x. – URL: http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11573-026-01282-x
Brühl, Volker, Radetzky, Marie-Therèse, Stolper, & Oscar A (2026). Shaping the compass? How sustainability preference elicitation guides investor demand. Journal of Business Economics. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11573-026-01282-x
Brühl, et al. “Shaping the compass? How sustainability preference elicitation guides investor demand.” Journal of Business Economics, 2026. doi:10.1007/s11573-026-01282-x.
@article{Brhl2026,
title = {Shaping the compass? How sustainability preference elicitation guides investor demand},
author = {Brühl and Volker and Radetzky and Marie-Therèse and Stolper and A., Oscar},
journal = {Journal of Business Economics},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1007/s11573-026-01282-x},
url = {http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s11573-026-01282-x}
}
This cross-national study identifies and analyzes the values organizations emphasize when articulating aspirational values found on corporate value statements. We use an interdisciplinary approach to draw on the Institutional Logics...
Emerging market multinationals (EM-MNEs) confront rising corporate social responsibility (CSR) and sustainability demands that act as nonmarket barriers to international expansion, yet how they build the substantive nonmarket...
The expanding array of production variants and the shifting demographic and organizational landscapes demand flexible and adaptable assembly systems. In this context, adaptive systems that can dynamically adapt to changing requirements,...
This research proposes the Generative AI-enhanced Flexible Adaptive Cyber Risk Management (FACRM) framework to address critical cybersecurity challenges in the U.S. healthcare sector. By integrating SAP-LAP theory with predictive...
Supply chain disruptions pose significant challenges for pharmaceutical supply chains (PSCs) leading to shortages of essential medicines and compromising patient care. Ensuring resilience in PSCs therefore requires an improved...