From compliance to competitiveness: how ESG creates lasting bank advantage
Аннотация
This paper investigates how Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) capability operates as a prudentially relevant meta-capability in European banking, transforming disclosure-driven compliance into strengthened capital resilience, efficiency and innovation. Grounded in the resource-based view and dynamic capabilities theory, it addresses an untested regulatory gap on whether ESG integration reinforces core supervisory levers- capital adequacy, technology-oriented intangible investment and cost efficiency- and how these levers transmit into market valuation and innovation that regenerate future ESG capability. Using a balanced panel of 117 listed banks from Germany, France, Spain, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom over 2015–2024, the paper estimates an eight-equation dynamic system via two-step System GMM to model persistence, unobserved heterogeneity and endogeneity across ESG scores, prudential ratios, efficiency, market valuation and R&D effort. Findings reveal that higher ESG scores are significantly associated with stronger capital adequacy, greater technology-oriented intangible investment and lower cost-to-income ratios; prudential strength, technology-oriented intangible investment and efficiency are rewarded through higher Tobin’s Q; and stronger valuation relaxes financing constraints, raising R&D intensity that subsequently upgrades ESG capability. To address measurement concerns regarding the intangibles-based technology proxy, the design adds a dedicated robustness check using RegTech disclosure intensity as an alternative technology-channel proxy. Overall, ESG emerges as a prudential and technology-related capability rather than a cosmetic reporting construct, creating a self-reinforcing ESG-risk-innovation cycle in a highly regulated banking setting. The paper provides dynamic, multi-stage evidence that ESG capability supports core supervisory objectives while simultaneously enhancing market-based competitiveness and innovation capacity in European banks, offering actionable insights for the implementation of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive and Basel-aligned supervisory review processes.