Trading in disorder: the crisis of globalization and the future of trade policy

Lamp, Nicolas
Journal of International Business Policy · Springer Nature · 2026-06-01 · DOI: 10.1057/s42214-026-00247-9

Аннотация

International trade is experiencing significant changes due to recent global events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, shifts in U.S. trade policy, China's industrial growth, geopolitical tensions, and the climate crisis. These changes have disrupted the traditional free trade system, creating uncertainty among governments, businesses, and academics. The article explores how trade policies are evolving across four key areas: the reasons governments regulate trade, the countries they choose to trade with, the goods and services they trade, and the tools they use to manage trade. This article examines the crisis of globalization and its impact on trade policies. It discusses how the traditional narrative of globalization, which emphasized open trade for mutual benefit, is being challenged by new perspectives. These include protectionist views that highlight the negative impacts of globalization on certain workers, narratives focusing on inequality and corporate power, and concerns about national security and sustainability. The article outlines how these narratives have influenced trade policies, leading to a shift away from broad free trade agreements towards more targeted and strategic trade policies. Governments are now prioritizing different goals, such as creating manufacturing jobs, ensuring national security, and promoting sustainability, which has led to a more complex and fragmented trade policy landscape. The article concludes that the changes in trade policy reflect a move towards a multipurpose approach, where governments balance various objectives rather than focusing solely on economic growth. This shift has significant implications for international business, as companies must navigate a more complex and politically charged trade environment. The author suggests that businesses need to be adaptable and responsive to changing trade policies and priorities. The article highlights the importance of collaboration between trade policy experts and international business scholars to better understand and respond to these changes. Future implications include the need for businesses to develop strategies that align with evolving trade policies and to engage with policymakers to shape the future of international trade. This text was initially drafted using artificial intelligence, then reviewed by the author(s) to ensure accuracy . O comércio internacional está passando por um período de profunda transformação. Políticos e observadores têm tentado identificar um paradigma que possa captaressa nova desordem. Este artigo argumenta que não está surgindo um único paradigma; em vez disso, as políticas comerciais estão mudando em várias dimensões simultaneamente. Podemos compreender essa nova complexidade traçando essas mudanças ao longo de quatro dimensões: os propósitos pelos quais os governos regulam o comércio, os parceiros com quem desejam que as empresas comercializem, os produtos e serviços que desejam ver comercializados e as ferramentas que utilizam para regular o comércio. Uma análise nesse sentido mostra que narrativas concorrentes sobre a globalização estão motivando os governos a adotar uma política comercial multifuncional; a adotar uma abordagem muito mais seletiva em relação aos seus parceiros comerciais; a desenvolver políticas comerciais adaptadas a produtos, serviços e cadeias de suprimentos específicos; e a empregar uma gama muito mais ampla de ferramentas para moldar as cadeias de suprimentos do que faziam há apenas uma década. El comercio internacional está atravesando un período de profunda agitación. Los políticos y observadores han estado intentando identificar un paradigma que pueda capturar este nuevo desorden. Este ensayo sostiene que no está surgiendo un único paradigma; en cambio, las políticas comerciales están cambiando en varias dimensiones simultáneamente. Podemos entender esta nueva complejidad rastreando esos cambios a lo largo de cuatro dimensiones: los propósitos para los cuales los gobiernos regulan el comercio, los socios con quienes quieren que las empresas comercien, los productos y servicios que desean que se comercialicen, y las herramientas que utilizan para regular el comercio. Un análisis en estas dimensiones muestra que las narrativas en competencia sobre la globalización están motivando a los gobiernos a adoptar una política comercial con múltiples propósitos; a tomar un enfoque mucho más selectivo hacia sus socios comerciales; a desarrollar políticas comerciales adaptadas a productos, servicios y cadenas de suministro específicos; y a emplear una gama mucho más amplia de herramientas para moldear cadenas de suministro, que ya hacían hace una década. 国际贸易正经历一场极大的动荡时期。政治家和观察家一直试图找到一个能够解释这种新混乱的范式。这篇文章认为,目前并没有单一的范式正在形成;相反,贸易政策正在多个维度上同时发生变化。我们可以通过沿着四个维度追踪这些变化来理解这种新的复杂性:政府监管贸易的目的、他们希望企业与哪些伙伴进行贸易、他们希望看到哪些产品和服务被贸易,以及他们用来监管贸易的工具。沿着这些思路进行分析表明,关于全球化的竞争性说法正在促使各国政府采取多目标的贸易政策;对其贸易伙伴采取更加选择性的态度;制定针对特定产品、服务和供应链的贸易政策;并且比十年前使用更加多样化的工具来影响供应链。 International trade is undergoing a period of profound upheaval. Politicians and observers have been trying to identify a paradigm that can capture the new disorder. This essay argues that no single paradigm is emerging; instead, trade policies are changing along several dimensions simultaneously. We can make sense of the new complexity by tracing those changes along four dimensions: the purposes for which governments regulate trade, the partners with whom they want businesses to trade, the products and services that they want to see traded, and the tools that they use to regulate trade. An analysis along these lines shows that competing narratives about globalization are motivating governments to embrace a multipurpose trade policy; to take a much more selective approach to their trading partners; to develop trade policies that are tailored to specific products, services, and supply chains; and to employ a much wider range of tools to shape supply chains than they did even a decade ago. Der internationale Handel durchläuft eine Phase tiefgreifender Veränderungen. Politiker und Politikbeobachter versuchen, ein Paradigma zu identifizieren, das die neue Unordnung erfassen kann. Dieser Essay argumentiert, dass kein einzelnes Paradigma entsteht; stattdessen verändern sich handelspolitische Maßnahmen gleichzeitig entlang mehrerer Dimensionen. Wir können die neue Komplexität verstehen, indem wir diese Veränderungen entlang von vier Dimensionen nachzeichnen: die Ziele, für die Regierungen den Handel regulieren, die Partner, mit denen sie möchten, dass Unternehmen Handel treiben, die Produkte und Dienstleistungen, die sie im Handel sehen wollen, und die Instrumente, die sie zur Regulierung des Handels einsetzen. Eine Analyse entlang dieser Linien zeigt, dass konkurrierende Narrative über die Globalisierung Regierungen dazu motivieren, eine mehrzweckorientierte Handelspolitik zu verfolgen; einen viel selektiveren Ansatz bei der Wahl ihrer Handelspartner zu verfolgen; handelspolitische Maßnahmen zu entwickeln, die auf spezifische Produkte, Dienstleistungen und Lieferketten zugeschnitten sind; und ein viel breiteres Spektrum an Instrumenten einzusetzen, um Lieferketten zu gestalten, als sie es noch vor einem Jahrzehnt taten. Le commerce international traverse une période de bouleversements profonds. Les politiciens et les observateurs tentent d’identifier un paradigme capable de saisir ce nouvel ordre désordonné. Cet essai soutient qu’aucun paradigme unique n’émerge; au contraire, les politiques commerciales évoluent simultanément selon plusieurs dimensions. Nous pouvons comprendre cette nouvelle complexité en retraçant ces changements selon quatre dimensions : les objectifs pour lesquels les gouvernements régulent le commerce, les partenaires avec lesquels ils souhaitent que les entreprises commercent, les produits et services qu’ils veulent voir échangés, et les outils qu’ils utilisent pour réguler le commerce. Une analyse selon ces axes montre que les récits concurrents sur la mondialisation incitent les gouvernements à adopter une politique commerciale à objectifs multiples ; à adopter une approche beaucoup plus sélective vis-à-vis de leurs partenaires commerciaux; à développer des politiques commerciales adaptées à des produits, services et chaînes d’approvisionnement spécifiques; et à utiliser une gamme d’outils beaucoup plus large pour façonner les chaînes d’approvisionnement qu’ils ne le faisaient il y a encore une décennie.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи