Argumentation Лингвистика и язык

Argumentation Absent Understanding: Minimal Threshold Conditions for Epistemically Adequate Uptake

Choi, Yongho
Springer Nature · 2026-08-20 · DOI 10.1007/s10503-026-09722-2

Аннотация

This article examines a gap between argument-as-object evaluation and uptake-in-context evaluation. An argument may be cogent while an addressee accepts its conclusion without preserving the conditions under which it is warranted. To diagnose this gap, the article develops a threshold model of epistemically adequate uptake comprising four analytically distinguishable checks: reconstructability, inferential grasp, scope sensitivity, and updatability. Reconstructability and inferential grasp concern the argument’s structure and support relation; scope sensitivity concerns the conclusion’s present warranted range; and updatability concerns which part of the accepted argumentative basis should be revised when new evidence or defeaters arise. In relation to Toulmin-style qualification, argument schemes, relevance-acceptability-sufficiency criteria, pragma-dialectical critical discussion, and Pinto’s invitation-to-inference account, the model adds an addressee-side test of whether established restrictions survive acceptance and later use. Cases involving expert opinion, analogy, and clinical risk scores show how the four checks can come apart and how conclusions can become scope-insensitive when transferred, reused as premises, or inflated beyond their warranted range. The proposal offers a normative account of uptake for theoretical argument evaluation rather than a measure of persuasion, belief change, or debate outcomes.

Читать у издателя →