The role of quality in optimising kidney exchanges

Kerek, Napsugár, Biró, Péter
Central European Journal of Operations Research · Springer Nature · 2026-11-19 · DOI: 10.1007/s10100-026-01040-y

Abstract

In kidney exchange programmes (KEPs), the recipients can register with their willing donors with the aim of exchanging them to receive fully compatible donors. In many national and international KEPs the participation of compatible pairs is also allowed, where the recipients can obtain better quality (i.e., younger or better-matching donors) through exchange. In this study, we extended the ENCKEP/Kepsoft simulator to measure the quality of the transplants with the standard LKDPI index and to take that into account in the screening for acceptable donors, in the optimisation policy, and also in the evaluation of the results. The aim of our research is to study the potential trade-off in the quality improvement versus the number of transplants by testing new hierarchical optimisation policies with a quality criterion, and quality filtering. Regarding the quality filtering, we studied two main approaches: the removal of low-quality donors for all patients, and the removal of donors who are worse (or not much better) quality for a recipient than their compatible donor. We conducted analyses on generated historical datasets for a five-year time interval with quarterly matching runs, by comparing the results of various policies regarding the number of transplants and the average quality of the transplant with a special attention to compatible pairs. Our results suggest that, by the removal of poor-quality transplant options, the quality improvement of the transplants can be significant with a minor loss in the total number of transplants.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles