From Contingency Misfit to Dynamic Capability Development: how an Extreme Disruption Reshapes Retail Supply Chain Resilience
Abstract
This study examines how an extreme disruption reshapes retail supply chain resilience through an integrated perspective combining contingency theory, the dynamic capabilities view, and Flexible Systems Management (FSM). Using a qualitative single-case study of a Portuguese retail firm affected by Covid-19, the research draws on six semi-structured interviews with managers from supply chain, commercial, sales, and logistics functions. The data were analyzed thematically according to the study’s theoretical framework and research objectives. The findings show that the pandemic created contingency misfit by disrupting the alignment between the retailer's supply chain design and environmental demands. In response, the firm accelerated e-commerce, expanded omnichannel operations, adjusted stock management, and strengthened transport coordination through dynamic capability processes of sensing, seizing, and reconfiguring. Resilience emerged as an adaptive, iterative process shaped by organizational learning, structural constraints, and flexibility–efficiency trade-offs. Retrospective managerial accounts suggest the strengthening of flexibility, selective redundancy, collaboration, responsiveness, and learning, alongside constraints related to capacity, specialization, cost, supplier dependence, and coordination. They also indicate differential retention of adaptive responses beyond the disruption, suggesting possible longer-term capability development rather than independently verified institutionalization. Through an integrated theoretical lens, this study explains resilience as a selective, constrained, and adaptive process following contingency misfit. Moreover, the findings suggest that retail managers should view resilience as a strategic systems capability, balancing flexibility with operational efficiency through organizational learning, cross-functional coordination, and continuous adaptation.