Water quality of temporary ponds along elevational gradients: the role of diatom indices
Abstract
Temporary ponds are highly dynamic freshwater ecosystems in which the transferability and ecological interpretation of diatom-based indices remain poorly understood. We evaluated the multivariate structure of 13 diatom indices in six temporary ponds distributed along an elevational gradient from 0 to 2000 m a.s.l. in protected areas of central Italy. Forty-one sampling observations were collected across seasons and analyzed using Pearson and Spearman’s correlations, principal component analysis (PCA), and linear mixed-effects models accounting for repeated observations within ponds. Most indices showed strong positive or negative associations, while PCA identified a dominant axis (PC1) explaining 53.98% of total variance. PC1 was highly robust to the sequential removal of strongly associated indices, indicating a stable shared signal among metrics. However, PC1 showed no significant association with either season or elevation, whereas between-pond heterogeneity was substantial. These findings suggest that diatom indices capture a common component of environmental variation in temporary ponds, but that this signal is strongly influenced by local site-specific conditions. Their application should therefore be considered exploratory and integrated with physicochemical and hydrological measurements.