Individual Differences in Cognition Humanities and social sciences
Relationships between empathy and executive function are contingent on measurement method
Abstract
Abstract Previous research suggests that cognitive empathy is positively correlated with executive function (EF), whereas affective empathy is negatively correlated with EF in adults. However, most of this research has assessed within-method correlations, which may reflect artifacts of shared method variance (e.g., reporting biases that create an apparent association between self-reported empathy and self-reported EF). In contrast, cross-method correlations are not susceptible to this issue. Here, therefore, we assessed the relationship between empathy (both cognitive and affective) and EF using a cross-method design in which empathy was measured by self-report questionnaire, and EF via task performance. In Study 1 ( N = 533 adults), EF was measured via two tasks, and the bivariate correlations between empathy and EF were assessed. In Study 2 ( N = 319 adults), EF was measured via three tasks, and the relationship between the latent variables of empathy and EF was assessed. Across both studies, there was no evidence of a relationship between self-reported empathy and task-based EF. This was so despite replicating the previously reported associations between self-reported empathy and self-reported EF. These findings suggest that the observed relationships between empathy and EF are contingent on both constructs being measured via the same method, highlighting an important qualification on the relationship between domain-general cognition and these socio-emotional processes in adults. The implications of these findings are discussed, including the possibility that empathy and EF are truly unrelated.